
UK media outlet The Guardian has ranked the 15 best UK video game magazines of all time, and Future's long-running EDGE has come out on top.
Penned by acclaimed journalist and author Keith Stuart – who has actually written for several of the publications in the list – the feature ranks some of the most beloved and influential mags of the past few decades.
The usual suspects are present and correct; Mean Machines comes in a number five, while its sister mag, C&VG, is in third place, just ahead of the iconic Super Play – but there's room for surprise inclusions, too.
The Richard Leadbetter-helmed Maximum, for example, only lasted for seven issues, yet it managed to find a small but receptive audience thanks to being filled with "detailed, rigorous articles on the key games of the era, accompanied by beautiful screenshots," as Stuart explains.
Official Sega Saturn Magazine, which was also edited by Richard Leadbetter, ranks even higher, coming in at number 12. Faced with the tricky prospect of covering a console that the UK had all but given up on, this publication delivered impeccable insight into Saturn's best games, eventually turning to Japanese imports to fill its page quota – something which made it a treasure trove for hardcore gamers.
You can see the full ranking here – let us know if you agree by posting a comment below.
[source theguardian.com]
Comments 9
That’s a solid list. I loved Maximum. Amazing photo spreads.
While short-lived, The Games Machine was a neat multi-format effort. Still have the R-Type/ PC Engine cover that helped drive my longing for that machine.
I fell out of love with Edge some time ago.
I was a subscriber for a long time time, but as I got older and gaming time became even more limited and precious, I was finding that reading Edge was actually making me quite cynical about video games. I felt like it was turning me against my hobby.
Then I realised what I was missing were the old magazines, that weren't so much 'journalism' - but more 'evangelism'.
I want to feel excited about videogames.
"Sometimes po-faced and pretentious, always with a heightened sense of its own importance" — it tracks that The Guardian put at number 1, then.
Edge is iconic, but I wouldn’t say it’s the best! Nice to see mags like PC Zone and GameMaster (which I assumed would be beneath The Grauniad’s radar) get mentioned.
My personal favourite is the successor to Super Play that didn’t make that list: N64 Magazine. I loved all its lives (Super Play/NGC/NGamer) but N64 Magazine just felt like the absolute peak of that team for me. Would be a clear Number 1 in my list! (My username is from that mag!)
Of all these mags, the only one i’ve seen on the list in the U.S. is Retro Gamer, and i’m surprised to see it so low.. it’s one if the best, if not the best gaming mag i’ve ever read and i pick one up whenever i get the chance.
But i’ve never read any of the others so i can only wonder, and not complain.
In the US in the 80s there was a line of toy cars called Mean Machines and the title reminds of those.
Edge was the "sophisticated" man's gaming mag at the time, but I would 100% put both Mean Machines and Super Play above it. They'd be my own top two gaming mags of all time. And mags like Maximum (shame that was so short lived) and C&VG would rank very highly too. Edge would possibly get the number five spot.
Basically, I think my top five would be:
1. Mean Machines
2. Super Play
3. Maximum
4. C&VG
5. Edge
MEGA was pretty special, quite grown up compared to most that were available around that time. The quality of the print and screenshots was exceptional too.
Official Playstation Magazine was another good one, and boy were those cover discs exceptional.
Clearly Amiga Power is the best, followed by Your Sinclair, PC Zone and then everything else!
Amiga power ftw!!!
and nice that retro gamer is on it... really keeps a bit of magazine spirit alive
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...