
When you consider that only a handful of the games that make up Konami's Ganbare Goemon series have been released outside of Japan, it's amazing that the franchise is held in such high regard in the West.
With its uniquely Japanese sense of humour and constant references to the country's complex history and deep folklore, it's certainly a hard sell when it comes to the international market – yet Goemon remains a popular character within the world of games, despite the fact that it's been almost 20 years since he last starred in a new mainline adventure.
The series began in 1986 with the arcade title Mr. Goemon, but Western players would have to wait until 1991 before they got to play The Legend of the Mystical Ninja, the Western version of Ganbare Goemon: Yukihime Kyūshutsu Emaki.
While this SNES instalment is viewed with a considerable amount of affection by Western fans, its subsequent 16-bit sequels are arguably far superior – it's just a shame they never got an English localisation.
However, the point of this poll isn't to lament what might have been but instead to rank all of the Goemon games to find out which one is best. Cast your vote below, and you'll help shape our running order.
Comments 31
The SNES games are the best ones I played. Indeed the sequels are superior to Legend of the Mystical Ninja, 2 and 3 are my favorites!
It's "Starring Goemon" on N64. It's basically when the series showed the most promise and they never went back to it. I'd bet good money that DS is the second best but It's so hard to translate so I haven't really played it. 3-5 on snes are great. The side scrolling platformers are mostly pretty boring, none of them even rate with the zelda/rcr ones.
I’ve only played the SNES and first N64 one, so can’t add much except that Mystical Ninja starring Goemon is a fantastic 3D adventure to this day!
I loved the one we got in the west on the SNES and the first N64 game was great too with a nice mix of gameplay styles with the mecha boss battles
I loved the first N64 adventure more than Mario 64. Loved it to bits. My favourite N64 game after Pilotwings 64.
I miss the Goemon series. If I owned a Switch I'd play its spiritual successor, Mameda no Bakeru.
This now has a fan-translation, if you have a modded Switch, btw.
I feel like the language barrier has stopped me from exploring these games in the past
Starring Goemon was incredible for a game from 1997. In a way, I think of it as the first 3D Zelda.
But I actually prefer Goemon's Great Adventure, despite the 2D-movement it is a much more polished game with better difficulty and more interesting quests. One of the most underrated N64 games!
@Poodlestargenerica The DS game is not bad, but is not great either. There are a lot of Goemon games that are better. It looks good, but the gameplay is very barebones
Well i only played one.
The first N64 one.
It was ..err something.
Goemon is my favorite video game series, I own all 26 games.
My favorite game of all time is The Legend of the Mystical Ninja on SNES. Very unique game, even unique in the Goemon series itself, as later entries didn't focus as much on town exploration, but earlier entries were a bit too tedious. I love its vibe and style, its gameplay, its variety, etc.
I know the general favorite is MNSG, and it's my second favorite, so I can understand. But yea I prefer LoMN.
@NinChocolate Most of the games have English fan translations now
As someone who has only played the first N64 game I can't really comment on the rest but I was dragged in by the theme song and how crazy the actual story was.
@DjinnFighter Yeah, it's definitely the best looking one. Too bad the gameplay doesn't live up to it.
The second SNES one. It blows the first, especially the western localisation, out of the water. Such a shame it wasn't localised. The first game ends up being a fairly tedious cost of living simulator as you have to continually grind for money to get armour and shoes and that goal increasing every time you take a hit and need to further replenish them for an ever increasing price. The sequel ditches all that nonsense and is just fun. And has nicer graphics.
For me I would say 2 (SNES) and 64.
@Damo that’s fantastic. Will definitely look those patches up 👍
I've played a bunch of Goemon games, and I love them all, but the first N64 game is just on a whole 'nother level. That game is crazy good.
Goemon 64 is definitely my favorite. It was really standout title early on in the n64 library. I hope it’s more available to play on modern hardware. Hopefully with so many companies mining their back catalog for remakes and re masters anything is possible. Plasma!!!!
I only played...
The Legend of the Mystical Ninja
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon
Goemon's Great Adventure
And it all started with a rental of
Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon. It was so fun and silly (PULASIMAAA!!), with great music (That town with the Moon Festival?), that I was hooked forever. Goemon's Great Adventure also had great music and I loved the multi-player. I actually didn't play The Legend of the Mystical Ninja until the Wii generation, but that was good classic 16-bit multi-player gaming that also had great music. If Rocket Knight can be dug up, I know this series can make a come back. C'mon Konami...
@Poodlestargenerica "Starring Goemon?" Well, it definitely wasn't "Starring Gatekeeper" LOL.
Also:
PLASMA!
@Lone_Beagle I just don't like calling it Mystical Ninja, because that was such a weird westernization
Re: "Bōken Jidai Katsugeki Goemon (PS2) 2000" --> FYI, the PS2 Goemon RPG has an English translation by Working Designs. The game was never approved for release; somehow just recently the protoype was leaked onto the internet.
See more at:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yS97Sc6jfsY
The Goemon series must have sold extremely poorly overseas for them to not release them worldwide. Unless Nintendo had some kind of stranglehold on the series, because I never saw it leave Nintendo consoles.
@DjinnFighter I'm pretty much in the same boat. I wouldn't say it's my favorite series ever, but it's up there. And I have all the games as well (including the GBA ports), and I have beaten all of them on original hardware (except for the PS2 one, I had to use emulation there, I don't have a Japanese PS2... yet!), so I could vote on all of them.
And I would also say that Legend of the Mystical Ninja on the SNES is probably my favorite with Mystical Ninja Starring Goemon being my second favorite. I fell in love with the series with the N64 entry, but it has quite some smaller and bigger problems (even if it's still a 10/10 game in my heart), the first SNES one is pretty much perfect aside from a few unfair platforming sections. The article says the sequels are arguably much better, but I don't really agree.
-2 comes the closest easily, but I think the Impact fights are not ideal, the soundtrack (while stellar here) is better in the first game, and I like that half of the game is basically in the style of the Famicom originals in the first one, while 2 is "just a platformer" with some towns. Still a fantastic game though.
-3 is a step down, because while the exploration is nice, it's too small and linear for a proper Zelda-like experience, and the sidequests are not great.
-Kirakira douchuu is like 2, but has less well designed stages in my opinion with a less good soundtrack. The mini-game bosses are a fun idea though.
The first SNES one is the one that feels most like a whole, well rounded game which was made with the most love.
@Dungeon00X There were 1 game on Arcade, 1 game on MSX2, 4 games on PS1 and 1 game on PS2. I think it sold well enough, otherwise Konami wouldn't have release 26 Goemon games. But they are so "japanese", I feel that was the reason why most of them were not localized.
@Krisi Nice! I feel that it's rare that people prefer the first one like me. We have very similar opinions on the games. I would rank the "main 6 games" like that: LoMN > MNSG > GGA > GG2 > GG4 > GG3
For 2, I think exactly the same thing
For 3, it was ambitious, but it failed in many areas. Soundtrack was not on the same level. It felt unpolished a bit. The future setting was not as interesting as the usual feudal japan setting. And some of the dungeons were a bit annoyingly designed, with tedious backtracking.... That said, I think it's still a good game.
I used to not like 4 because of its space setting, mixed with sports theme. But I now like it. The music is great, the graphics are very good. There are some very good ideas in a lot of stages. I'm not a fan of the minigame bosses though... I suck at Puyo Puyo, I hate that it's a mandatory part of the game.
@DjinnFighter I would rank them similarly, but I would put Great Adventure a bit further back. The platforming in that one was arguably the worst of the "main" games, and it had some unforgiving and fetchquest-y parts. It's still great though.
For 4, wasn't only Goemon's planet sports themed? Also the thing about enemies only giving money when you hit them with that ball thingy was just super weird. And I'm horrible at Puyo Puyo as well, but I still found the variety pretty nice.
Also here's my opinion on the others:
-Mr. Goemon was pretty fun if not amazing, I was quite addicted to the high score chase some years back, I was even very high (like top 3?) on the scoreboard.
-1 and 2 on the Famicom I found to be very good if a bit repetitive, and while 1 was a bit less varied and a bit more hard, its higher consistency and more simplistic charm was a bit better for me. The MSX version was pretty bad for its incredibly slow speed and randomly warping gates.
-Gaiden 1 and 2 were alright RPGs with better than average visuals and music. Tengu-tou was pretty meh, but Mononoke douchuu was a surprisingly fun monster catching RPG, but nothing amazing.
-Sarawareta Ebisumaru would be a pretty top tier Game Boy game if it wasn't for the stage where you play as the girl (I forget her name) and you have to precisely platform between small islands for half an hour. Still a great game though.
-Kurofune-tou is just horrible in pretty much every way.
-Seikuushi Dynamites Arawaru is pretty much just a Goemon 2 wannabe on the go. It's still pretty nice and ambitious for a GBC game.
-Soreyuke Ebisumaru is an alright puzzler. I beat it in one sitting like 10 years ago, and I never really wanted to return, but I still had some fun.
-Mononoke Sugoroku is an alright card fight-board game combination. It's not exactly well balanced, and luck has too much to do with it, but I still had some fun.
-Uchuu Kaizoku Akogingu is kinda like a better version of 3 on the SFC.
-Kuru Nara Koi is poorly made and enemies have way too much HP. The cutscenes are nice though. And it's still a lot better than the second GB game.
-Ooedo daikaiten is 2 again with lots of recycled content. It's still mostly well made, and in a vacuum, it's a good game, it's just not really original.
-Shin Sedai Shuumei was surprisingly fun for me despite its futuristic theme, and it had a great soundtrack (with songs mostly from the N64 games). New Age Shutsudou however felt really rushed for me with some bad decisions.
-The other GBA ports were fine. 1+2 had pretty bad sound and no multiplayer, but at least you could play the mini-games freely in the main menu.
-Bouken Jidai Katsugeki is too large for its own good, content is really spread out, and it's not balanced well in any way or in any sense of the word. There is still some fun to be had, but it's very rough.
-Toukai Douchuu is one I played a long time ago, and what I remember is that it looked really nice, and it played like a better 3/Akogingu.
...I didn't leave anything out, right?
Okay, so the girl's name was Miko apparently. By the way, it's crazy that we found out at the end of Ebisumaru's debut game that they are actually a girl who were cursed, and it literally never comes back again in the series. Other than some mild references in Ebisumaru having some girly abilities very rarely.
The first Mystical Ninja on the SNES for me. Closely followed by the first N64 outing, which might have won were it not for the infuriating camera 😂. I need to dig in to the other games properly at some point, and have almost pressed 'BUY' on GenkiVideoGames, on the SFC games that never made it here quite a few times 😂
first 64 game was amazing and the first one I played. I later went back and played the snes games and while I enjoyed them, they weren't as special as the first 64 game to me. I blame that on timing. 64 made 3d gaming exciting for me. This and Bomberman 64 had me all in on series I never messed with in the past.
@Poodlestargenerica I feel the same. I also feel this way about Bomberman 64.
GANBARE GOEMON 2 ON SNES ITS GANBARE GOEMON 2 ON SNES GANBARE GOEMON 2 ON SNES IS THE ONLY ANSWER TO THIS
Leave A Comment
Hold on there, you need to login to post a comment...