I didn't play this one, but I loved Commander Keen and the original Duke Nukem growing up, so I have a lot of nostalgia for Apogee-style games in general.
@GhaleonUnlimited I guess it wouldn't be any different as long as it's all clean room and you're not distributing their copyrighted code/ROMs. It's pretty common in the arcade world for there to be custom hardware designed for just one game, so it kind of just comes with the territory.
@PinballBuzzbro I don't blame you for feeling the way you do. However, it paints a picture of exactly what I was afraid of to have all these controversies hitting at once. It really puts a damper on the entire hobby, and the worst part is I don't know how to reassure you that it's not all like this, especially when you and many others have already been burned. A lot of people's trust has been broken by companies that were once doing an excellent job, but have really dropped the ball – myself and my partner included.
@spysmily Oh, also, save states and suspending your game are possible on FPGA, and even on original hardware with certain Everdrive models, but it generally works better on software emulation. – That's actually one of the main reasons I still sometimes use software emulation over original hardware, even if I prefer hardware.
@spysmily Rather than thinking about it in negative terms, consider this: software emulation is still really good for enhancements – i.e. resolution, frame rate, or adding new features on the emulator level, particularly for newer 3D consoles. You can definitely do enhancements in FPGA too, but software is still king there in my opinion.
It's also still not really viable in the consumer space to do FPGA implementations of something like Nintendo GameCube or Xbox 360/PS3 yet. That's another reason why software emulation is still relevant.
(I also considered netplay, particularly for arcade games, which hasn't been done on FPGA systems yet to my knowledge. I'm not sure if that's even possible or not; it feels like a huge challenge, but I don't feel certain enough to say it isn't possible.)
Of course, when it comes to Japanese game history there's also a language and cultural barrier to contend with. Things have been "uncovered" by westerners that could have been common knowledge in Japan this entire time. But that's not always the case – plenty of media is at risk of being lost to time as well.
@HammerGalladeBro No, you're absolutely right. There is a real issue where much of gaming history is only told from an English-speaking and often USA-specific perspective.
I'm from Australia and it's even similar for us – we also had our own computer/gaming history and our own magazines that are difficult to find today. So I totally sympathize.
Yeah I'm very much in agreement here. Software-based emulation and FPGA (which you could consider "hardware emulation") are simply good at different things in my view.
There's nothing to be gained for us by pitting the two technologies against each other. – There is, however, a marketing incentive for Analogue to brand their products as "zero emulation". Which is, yeah, misleading, and by design.
As someone whose been a part of the SRB2 community for nearly two decades, this is HUGE. I'm glad that this game and it's developers can still surprise me all these years later.
I adore these releases, but I super regret not importing the triple pack for the collection when it was brand new. All I have is the one volume we did get, and some of the individual titles digitally.
I'm usually really sensitive to input latency and there's some absolutely shocking examples of it on Switch, even in new games, but I honestly never felt like the NES and SNES NSO apps were all that bad. – and I do play on a real SNES on a CRT too, so I have experience with both and can tell the difference. Particularly in something like Mega Man vs the legacy collections.
That said I do trust Voultar's judgement on things like that. Perhaps my own tolerance is a bit more lenient.
Awesome! I've been loving these ports already, but I love seeing new features like this! I do indeed remember these backgrounds from the 3D Classics version.
Far from me to downplay the importance of these unique games being preserved, but I've also always been endlessly fascinated by the keitai version of Rockman X. 👀
Comments 30
Re: DOS Lovers Rejoice! The Beloved Apogee Game 'BioMenace' Is Being Remastered For Steam
I didn't play this one, but I loved Commander Keen and the original Duke Nukem growing up, so I have a lot of nostalgia for Apogee-style games in general.
Re: Toaplan's Tiger-Heli Is Getting A New Port For The Atari 2600+ & Atari 7800+
I love this! It's great to see new ports of classic games in the Atari+ catalogue.
Re: "Free SNK From The Saudi Royal Family" - Fans Aren't Pleased About Fatal Fury's Celebrity Fighters
Man, I don't know what I'll do, but I can tell you I was excited for this game before and this has just made everything feel incredibly weird.
Re: Konami Is Reviving A Long Forgotten DS & Game Boy Series For The Switch 2
Huh! I learned something today!
Re: Sega's Super Monaco GP Has Just Got A Handy New SRAM Hack
Bless Damien and the photos he takes for these articles.
Re: Funding For The Most Advanced Killer Instinct Emulator Ever Made Has Been Pulled
@GhaleonUnlimited I guess it wouldn't be any different as long as it's all clean room and you're not distributing their copyrighted code/ROMs. It's pretty common in the arcade world for there to be custom hardware designed for just one game, so it kind of just comes with the territory.
Re: This New Atari Watch Sets Out To Combine The Worlds Of Retro Gaming & Fitness Tracking
Honestly, I dig it!
Re: Taki Udon Shows Off The UI For His SuperStation One FPGA PS1
Huh, well I'll be damned! I was expecting just the classic MiSTer menu, but this looks quite special!
Re: "These Short Games Mean Nothing To Me" - Retro-Bit Translator Denies Wrongdoing In "Baffling" Rant
@PinballBuzzbro I don't blame you for feeling the way you do. However, it paints a picture of exactly what I was afraid of to have all these controversies hitting at once. It really puts a damper on the entire hobby, and the worst part is I don't know how to reassure you that it's not all like this, especially when you and many others have already been burned. A lot of people's trust has been broken by companies that were once doing an excellent job, but have really dropped the ball – myself and my partner included.
Re: Random: Distributor Koch Appears To Think The Intellivision Amico Is Still Coming
@slider1983 They'd have to update a lot more; they haven't traded under the "Koch Media" name in a long time, instead going by Plaion these days.
Re: Review: Stories from Sol: The Gun-Dog (Switch) - A Mech-Based Adventure That Plays As Good As It Looks
God this game looks so cool.
Re: The Team That Ported GTA 3 To Dreamcast Is Bringing Vice City Over Next
Dang, they just keep delivering more than I ever could have asked!
(I guess it's not that unexpected given that the two games' reverse engineering projects share a common codebase, but still. Wild!)
Re: This Week's Arcade Archives Game May Be Worth Skipping
A game so nice it fits on a single side of a Famicom disk.
Re: Creator Of New Open-Source Game Boy Disagrees That FPGA Is Superior To Software Emulation
@spysmily Oh, also, save states and suspending your game are possible on FPGA, and even on original hardware with certain Everdrive models, but it generally works better on software emulation. – That's actually one of the main reasons I still sometimes use software emulation over original hardware, even if I prefer hardware.
Re: Creator Of New Open-Source Game Boy Disagrees That FPGA Is Superior To Software Emulation
@spysmily Rather than thinking about it in negative terms, consider this: software emulation is still really good for enhancements – i.e. resolution, frame rate, or adding new features on the emulator level, particularly for newer 3D consoles. You can definitely do enhancements in FPGA too, but software is still king there in my opinion.
It's also still not really viable in the consumer space to do FPGA implementations of something like Nintendo GameCube or Xbox 360/PS3 yet. That's another reason why software emulation is still relevant.
(I also considered netplay, particularly for arcade games, which hasn't been done on FPGA systems yet to my knowledge. I'm not sure if that's even possible or not; it feels like a huge challenge, but I don't feel certain enough to say it isn't possible.)
Re: Why Famitsu's 'Perfect' Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Review Highlights "The Sorry State Of Preservation"
Of course, when it comes to Japanese game history there's also a language and cultural barrier to contend with. Things have been "uncovered" by westerners that could have been common knowledge in Japan this entire time. But that's not always the case – plenty of media is at risk of being lost to time as well.
Re: Why Famitsu's 'Perfect' Zelda: Ocarina Of Time Review Highlights "The Sorry State Of Preservation"
@HammerGalladeBro No, you're absolutely right. There is a real issue where much of gaming history is only told from an English-speaking and often USA-specific perspective.
I'm from Australia and it's even similar for us – we also had our own computer/gaming history and our own magazines that are difficult to find today. So I totally sympathize.
Re: Creator Of New Open-Source Game Boy Disagrees That FPGA Is Superior To Software Emulation
Yeah I'm very much in agreement here. Software-based emulation and FPGA (which you could consider "hardware emulation") are simply good at different things in my view.
There's nothing to be gained for us by pitting the two technologies against each other. – There is, however, a marketing incentive for Analogue to brand their products as "zero emulation". Which is, yeah, misleading, and by design.
Re: Fan Developer Gives Daytona USA A Virtua Racing-Style Makeover
Yeah that's definitely based on the existing arcade version.
I have often wondered how that supposed 32X version would have looked though. It always seemed like a huge ask.
Re: Become A Travelling Salesman In 'Merchant 64' - A Cozy N64-Inspired Adventure For PC
It's cute! Gonna keep an eye on this one.
Re: Kero Quest 64 Is A New N64-Style Platformer From Veteran Mario & Zelda Modders
Perhaps I'm biased since I can personally vouch for some of the people behind this project, but this is definitely one to watch.
Re: Sega's Shinobi Has Been Unofficially Ported To Neo Geo, And You Can Grab It Now
@Serpenterror Well, good news. There does actually happen to be an unrelated port of classic Shinobi to the Sega Genesis in development too.
Re: Fan-Made Classic 'Sonic Robo Blast 2' Comes To Sega 32X
As someone whose been a part of the SRB2 community for nearly two decades, this is HUGE. I'm glad that this game and it's developers can still surprise me all these years later.
Re: Anniversary: Sega's '3D Reprint Archives' Celebrates 10 Years
I adore these releases, but I super regret not importing the triple pack for the collection when it was brand new. All I have is the one volume we did get, and some of the individual titles digitally.
Re: Sorry, But That Nightmarish Lara Croft PS1 Controller Isn't Real
I don't know if I should be disappointed or grateful. I think I'm simultaneously both.
Re: To The Shock Of Absolutely Nobody, Sega Is Trying To Shut Down The SuperSega FPGA Project
"If you can find it in your heart to forgive me, send one dollar to Sorry Dude, 742 Evergreen Terrace, Springfield."
Re: "Absolutely Horrid" - Is Nintendo Switch Online's Emulation Really That Bad?
I'm usually really sensitive to input latency and there's some absolutely shocking examples of it on Switch, even in new games, but I honestly never felt like the NES and SNES NSO apps were all that bad. – and I do play on a real SNES on a CRT too, so I have experience with both and can tell the difference. Particularly in something like Mega Man vs the legacy collections.
That said I do trust Voultar's judgement on things like that. Perhaps my own tolerance is a bit more lenient.
Re: Polymega Gets Classic Arcade Games Via Physical "Polymega Collection" Series
The Polymega perhaps still isn't for me, but this honestly pretty cool!
Re: Kid Icarus's Unofficial SNES Port Is About To Get Even Better
Awesome! I've been loving these ports already, but I love seeing new features like this! I do indeed remember these backgrounds from the 3D Classics version.
Re: 9 Capcom Mobile Games – Including A Devil May Cry Spin-Off – Have Been Saved From Digital Oblivion
Far from me to downplay the importance of these unique games being preserved, but I've also always been endlessly fascinated by the keitai version of Rockman X. 👀